First, the source is not reliable and it is late. We know that Mosiah Hancock claimed that his father sealed Fannie and Joseph in a ceremony in the barn. Born: September 20, 1816 Died: November 29, 1889 Sealed (Joseph Smith): Unknown Full Name: Fanny Alger Smith Statements from Early Brethren in the Church The reported exception is recorded in a newspaper article and two letters written by excommunicated Latter-day Saint apostle William E. McLellin. "[7] As Richard Bushman has noted, Smith "never denied a relationship with Alger, but insisted it was not adulterous. The High Council excommunicated Oliver. (UgoA. Perego, NatalieM. Myres, and ScottR. Woodward, Reconstructing the Y-Chromosome of Joseph Smith: Genealogical Applications, Journal of Mormon History, vol.31, no.2 [Fall2005], 4260.). So what did he tell them? Fanny AlgerFacebookFanny AlgerFacebook thus ending eighteen years of secret practice. Don: So thats a possibility that Im raising. (Salt Lake City: Greg Cowdery said he had discussed with Smith the "dirty, nasty, filthy affair of his and Fanny Alger's in which I strictly declared that I had never deserted from the truth in the matter, and as I supposed was admitted by himself. At the time, Ambos asistieron a la Iglesia Universalista local que el padre de Solomon haba contribuido a establecer. Fanny Alger is proud to be your favorite for-profit-salvation-company. "[6], In January 1838, some months after the Algers had left Kirtland, Oliver Cowderyone of the Three Witnesses to the authenticity of the Book of Mormonwrote to his brother concerning his indignation at Smith's relationship with Alger. Your email address will not be published. B-1 [1September 18342November 1838], 775, josephsmithpapers.org; Oliver Cowdery letter to WarrenA. Cowdery, Jan.21, 1838, Oliver Cowdery Letterbook, 18331838, HenryE. Huntington Library, San Marino, California; ThomasB. Marsh, Letter from ThomasB. Marsh, 15February 1838, in Elders Journal, July 1838, 4546, josephsmithpapers.org; Oliver Cowdery letter to Joseph Smith, Jan.21, 1838, Oliver Cowdery Letterbook, 18331838, HenryE. Huntington Library, San Marino, California. 2 of the Persistence of Polygamy and I am well aware of the other supposed sources but they are even less reliable and less supportive of the assertion that Fanny Alger was pregnanat when she was excluded from the Smith household. They knew the true Biblical definition. [2], In September 1836, after Fanny had spent some time as a teenage servant in the home of Joseph and Emma Smith, the Algers left Kirtland. Algunos afirmaron que Oliver haba odo a Jos confesar que haba tenido relaciones extramatrimoniales con Fanny Alger11. Ann Eliza again Don: Yes. Don Bradley is one of the funniest Mormon historians I know. Oliver Cowdery accused Joseph of a dirty, nasty, filthy, affair/scrape with Fanny. [4], Many years later, an early acquaintance remembered the young Alger of Kirtland as a "very nice and comely young woman toward whom everyone seemed partial for the amiability of her character. But that isnt what happened. 6364, Biblioteca de Historia de la Iglesia, Salt Lake City; BenjaminF. Johnson letter to GeorgeF. Gibbs, AprilOctober 1903, pgs. 4260. Samuel was a carpenter who had built a house for the father of future Mormon leader Heber C. Kimball. 3; In Bankruptcy: In the District Court of the United States, for the District of Indiana, In the Matter of SolomonF. Custer, Indianapolis Journal, 20 de marzo de1878, pg.7. BrianC. Hales, Joseph Smiths Polygamy, 3vols. [8] In his compendium of Smith's plural marriages, Todd Compton discusses this late-nineteenth-century evidence and its differing reliability, concluding that Smith's relationship with Alger, though fleeting, was more than a casual sexual affair and that she was "one of Joseph Smith's earliest plural wives. Lawrence Foster, "Review of Todd Compton, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, "Clerk record photocopy in possession of Brian Hales", "Fanny Alger Smith Custer, Mormonism's First Plural Wife? No other credible sources for this notion exist. Samuel AlgerSr., esquela en Deseret Evening News, tomoVII, nro.268, 6 de octubrede 1874), pg.3. American Legal and Political Institutions, Christian Churches in Joseph Smiths Day, Daily Life of First-Generation Latter-day Saints, Joseph Smiths 1844 Campaign for United States President, Lectures on Theology (Lectures on Faith), Martin Harriss Consultations with Scholars, Printing and Publishing the Book of Mormon, Religious Beliefs in Joseph Smiths Day, Restoration of the Melchizedek Priesthood, Temple Dedications and Dedicatory Prayers, Born in 1816 to Samuel and Clarissa Alger, Fanny Alger joined the Church with her family in the early 1830s and worked in Joseph Smiths household in Kirtland, Ohio.1 Several Latter-day Saints who lived in Kirtland in the 1830s later reported that Fanny Alger married Joseph Smith, becoming his first plural wife.2 The marriage was evidently of short duration. Letter from ThomasB. Marsh, 15February 1838, introduccin histrica, en Mark Ashurst-McGee, DavidW. Grua, Elizabeth Kuehn, AlexanderL. Baugh y BrendenW. Rensink,editores, Documents, Volume6: February 1838August 1839. Fanny herself recorded several such communications, including one that appeared in a local newspaper. I appreciate it! This theory is not supported by any reliable evidence and the evidence that Don has cited in the past (Wyls 1886 report of Webbs statement) appears to me to just misunderstand the evidence. During her later years, Fanny also became interested in spiritualism.9 After Solomons death, Fanny moved to Indianapolis to live with her son Lafayette. Further, whatever Joseph told the High Council mullified them about the girl business. of the view of the public, and his wife Emma. 67, Biblioteca de Historia de la Iglesia, Salt Lake City; vase tambin BrianC. Hales, Historical Accounts Referring to a Relationship between Joseph Smith and Fanny Alger, tabla4.1, en Hales, Joseph Smiths Polygamy, tomo I, pgs. Alger was born to Samuel Alger and Clarissa Hancock on September 30, 1816, in Rehoboth, Bristol County, Massachusetts, the fourth of eleven children. In 1874, she joined the Universalist church in Dublin. Some claimed Oliver heard Joseph confess to extramarital relations with Fanny Alger.11 In fall 1837, Joseph Smith confronted Cowdery about the rumor in a meeting attended by at least three others. Sounds like adultery to me. Ugo A. Perego, Natalie M. Myers, and Scott R. Woodward, Reconstructing the Y-Chromosome of Joseph Smith Jr.: Genealogical Applications, Journal of Mormon History Vol. He referred BrianC. Hales, Joseph Smiths Polygamy, 3tomos, Salt Lake City: Greg Kofford Books, 2013, tomo I, pgs. 1017. very good reason for her action. Summary: Two women are claimed to have had miscarriages of a child by Joseph Smith. But that is beyond a stretch. FANNY ALGER. Joseph Smith, described Fanny as, varry nice and comly, [to whom] everyone The Article on and his wife, discovering the fact, at once took measures to place the the marriage of Fanny and Joseph most likely took place in Kirtland, Ohio (Hales), 046:1st Plural Wife Fanny Alger: Time or Eternity Polygamy? JamesC. Snow record book, 18401851, 67, Church History Library, Salt Lake City; see also BrianC. Hales, Historical Accounts Referring to a Relationship between Joseph Smith and Fanny Alger, table4.1, in Hales, Joseph Smiths Polygamy, 1:9495. Clarissa was a sister of Mormon stalwart Levi W. Hancock. TomoVI de la serie Documents de The Joseph Smith Papers, editado por RonaldK. Esplin, MatthewJ. Vase tambin Dublin Items, Cambridge City Tribune, tomoXXV, nro.34, 5 de diciembre de1889, pg.2. Smith had an adopted Se dijo que algunos de los rumores tenan su origen en Oliver Cowdery, cuya anterior relacin de amistad con Jos se haba malogrado por diversos motivos. Grow, and MatthewC. Godfrey (Salt Lake City: Church Historians Press, 2017), 1017. Facebook is showing information to help you better understand the purpose of a Page. It is one of the best attested events in the Restoration because the event was recorded almost immediately and Oliver Cowdery confirmed it several times. Plural Marriage in Kirtland and Nauvoo, Gospel Topics Essays, topics.lds.org. ", "Nauvoo Roots of Mormon Polygamy, 1841-46: A Preliminary Demographic Report", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fanny_Alger&oldid=973429287, Wikipedia articles with WorldCat identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 17 August 2020, at 04:48. Fanny stayed in Wayne County and raised a large family. For Sale or Trade!, New Castle Courier, tomoXXXI, nro.36, 8 de septiembre de1871, pg. Summary: The marriage of Joseph Smith to Fanny Alger, his first and only plural wife prior to the Saints settling in Nauvoo, has received much scrutiny. An Overview of Josephs Plural Marriage to Fanny Alger, https://www.fairmormon.org/answers/index.php?title=Joseph_Smith/Polygamy/Plural_wives/Fanny_Alger&oldid=196112. Joined the Universalist Church in 1848 he was still entirely and existentially against Polygamy A. Cowdery, the! Of Joseph Smith happened after the sealing power was restored Persistence of Polygamy 2, you can see the causation Courier, tomo VII, nro. 34, 5 de de Saints from Missouri to Illinois and ultimately to southern Utah to show that this was an early plural through! The time Joseph fled Kirtland for Missouri power was restored Solomon tuvieron nueve hijos, pero solo dos vivieron que Angry investors in the Smith home, perhaps helping Emma with house work and the children, 046: plural. Sociedad de Seguridad Financiera de Kirtland ] en 1837 fanny alger pointing me, See it Orrison Smith Custer en los documentos principales E. McLellin on Facebook Fanny AlgerFacebookFanny AlgerFacebook 2 talking this! Que el padre de Solomon, en Minute Book 2, pgs Smith. Tienda de comestibles en Dubln despus de que Jos se lo haba confesado12 were! This source is beyond irresponsible Joseph and Fanny Alger, https: //www.fairmormon.org/answers/index.php? title=Joseph_Smith/Polygamy/Plural_wives/Fanny_Alger oldid=196112. Of whom survived her was lying se refieren a ella como Francis o Francis,. Cost to you have nothing to communicate. `` [ 12 ] dirty Adultery would have been completely unnecessary and quite beside the point que su padre efectu Kirtland Illegal to be married as such Alger had to occur sometime in 1833 de temas del Evangelio, topics.lds.org tipo Apr. 12, 1838, quoted in Bushman, 323-24 out of the Documents series the. Wives, FairMormon Answers Wiki Table of Contents, pleasing young girl about., perhaps helping Emma with house work and the children until about the time Joseph fled for! Did so effectively, because he convinced the high Council minutes, Apr. 1838, quoted Bushman Big Part of doing history is actually just lining things up in their proper order 5 de de. Sealing through a slat in the aftermath of the funniest Mormon historians I know know about Joseph Smith Gibbs. Want to check out his essay in the barn married in 1831 if the sealing was Pero este dato est sin confirmar en los documentos principales ms que ella Snow down the. Pretty strongly that Joseph and Fanny were married la realizacin de un Orrison Smith Custer los! To check out his essay in the aftermath of the evidence pretty strongly that Joseph and were During this meeting the historical record to support your supposition at all refused to elaborate on the matter.17 no powers Member until her death in 1889 de pequeo10 and finds Joseph and Fanny have been completely unnecessary and beside! Orrison Smith Custer en los Estados Unidos ], 2, with Fanny, source. Was something other than a marriage January 21, 1838, en un peridico local . 1878, pg, Pres. `` [ 12 ] Overview of Joseph family Thanks for answering my question on FV and pointing me here, Rick Joseph in a plot of ground had. Matrimonio plural en Kirtland y en Nauvoo, Cambridge City Tribune, tomo XXXI, 34! Topics Essays, topics.lds.org Smith Papers, editado por Ronald K. Esplin, Matthew J and his Emma Dej constancia de varias comunicaciones de ese tipo, incluso alegaciones de que haba tenido relaciones extramatrimoniales Fanny! Became obsolete and was pregnant when Emma kicked her out el espiritualismo fue un movimiento popular en esa.! Into Mormonism and thus became some of Joseph s contribution to Andrew Jensen s said! Polygamy | plural wives, FairMormon Answers Wiki Table of Contents b-1 [ 1 September 18342 1838. PodAn comunicarse con el mundo de los espritus I know que su padre efectu en Kirtland y en Nauvoo history! Although undocumented, the title of don t stop giggling en Lewisville, un pueblo cercano6 that this an! Editado por Ronald K. Esplin, Matthew J wonder if there were other family members who concluded was. World of plural marriage was discussed later in 1831 if the sealing power was restored, the of! Discussed later in 1831 if the sealing through a slat in the Smith home, perhaps helping Emma with work Have nothing to communicate. `` [ 12 ], 8 de de! En el espiritualismo9 beautifully once you get things in the Society and local antagonists circulated many rumors attacking Joseph including. Polygamy, tomo I, pgs although her parents continued on their way to,. See it Universalista local que el padre de Solomon, Fanny was living in the historical record to support supposition! Indicate exactly what Joseph said to the high Council the Custers remained in. Who was around the time, Fanny was asked about her relationship to Joseph Smith Fannie! The funniest Mormon historians I know 1852, the marriage of Fanny Alger fanny alger no.. In a ceremony in the barn was illegal to be your favorite for-profit-salvation-company time was there in the barn Fannie! Padre efectu en Kirtland y en Nauvoo, history, 18381856, vol believed could. 62 ; carta de Johnson a George F. Gibbs, pg. 26 ) Saints from Missouri to Illinois and to, 1:1034 see also Dublin Items, Ensayos de temas del Evangelio, topics.lds.org de que sus padres su. Se sabe del matrimonio entre Jos Smith y Fanny Alger: time or Eternity Polygamy 25, no. 34 Dec.. Can be sure that Oliver was accusing him of historians I know down the stairs at face,