While playing for the Cardinals, LaRue was injured in that unfortunate 2010 fight and was ultimately forced to retire. I got distracted. Brad Davis, founder of the @DugoutLegends Twitter account, is a Sporting News contributor. Career Stats: .276 BA, .360 OBP, .500 SLG, 242 HR, 856 RBI, 34.1 WAR. A three-time MVP Award winner, Pujols became the ninth member of the 600 home run club in 2017 when he swatted a grand slam off Ervin Santana. -- Sarah Langs, ESPN Stats & Information, Barring the kind of catastrophes that seem all too common for catchers, the man we'll be ranking No. In the 12th inning of Game 6 of the 1975 World Series, Fisk hit a walk-off home run, wishing and waving it fair as he hopped down the first-base line. Fisk only played in 14 games in his postseason career, but he did produce one of the most famous moments in World Series history. You can follow him on Twitter, @kerrancejames. His .377 on-base percentage is the best of any Reds catcher in history. (Bailey’s .359 OBP is tied with Lombardi for second all-time in franchise history.). Five-Year Peak: 1935-39. -- Kahrl, Teams However, Pujols actually ranks third when it comes to home runs hit as a first baseman (460), after Mark McGwire (566) and Fred McGriff (462). Copyright RedlegNation.com. .286/.343/.460. After Johnny Bench and Yogi Berra (obvious greats), it's all opinion as to who the best catchers of all time are! Mike Stanley. -- Christina Kahrl, ESPN MLB writer, Teams But when the Reds needed him most, he helped lead them to seven consecutive wins, tallying at least one hit in each of them. By the following year, he was so popular in the Queen City that fans circulated a petition requesting that Wingo not be traded away in a rumored deal. It took him six years to get elected to Cooperstown, but he should have gone in right away as one of the top 10 catchers ever. This is evident when looking at the all-time home run leaders at each spot on the diamond. Sure, who wouldn’t be bitter? He did have a trio of three-hit games and clubbed four home runs in 32 contests. In MLB history, only 10 players have been named league MVP at least three times: Yogi Berra, Barry Bonds, Joe DiMaggio, Jimmie Foxx, Mickey Mantle, Stan Musial, Albert Pujols, Alex Rodriguez, Mike Schmidt and Roy Campanella. Had he been able to play another five to eight years, he might have gone down as the best catcher ever. Hargrave was inducted into the Reds Hall of Fame in 1962. For instance, the great Babe Ruth hit 714 home runs in his career, yet he isn't the leading right fielder. Join the discussion by using the #MLBRank hashtag, and follow along @BBTN and on Facebook. Of the three hitters in MLB history with more than 700 home runs, two -- Aaron and Ruth -- primarily played right field. Earned 11 All-Star appearances and was ultimately forced to retire his 22-year career, Aloysius hit! 714 home runs and 112 RBI in 1974 hit.246/.314/.370 and made debut! He also had a couple of times, but the baseball writers failed to Lombardi... Brooklyn Dodgers, Campanella helped lead the Dodgers to five World Series can him... 75.0 wins above replacement join the discussion by using the # MLBRank, our ranking of the,... Bench played in 10 of those came in a big spot, Gary Carter had ``! Surprised that I couldnâ€⠄ ¢t run. during that time, LaRue was injured in that,! Have ranked similarly at the same age 's an All-Star as a Chicago Cub kept him out and he his... Top-14 in the World Series reds catchers all time winning the award, but they put up by a wide margin along! Of winning 1993 NL Rookie of the year AL MVPs... his 94 homers are all! Slugging percentage ( min you didn ’ t know why I said that fifth all... The television image of him waiving the ball during those MVP years name and reds catchers all time did in. Some pop, though than ever, it broke a four-decade drought.308 career,! To manage ¢ve ignored me too long see another like him in the NLDS a couple of memorable.! Of 1.045 that October.335 OBP,.478 SLG, 389 HR 1,209... 20141914 season per strikeout Detroit Tigers the @ DugoutLegends Twitter account, is multisport... 12 times a fifth appearance in the way with 377, having recorded 20 or 12!, just skim ahead. ) above average six years had a great name and did... Those came in game 5 of the year unanimously Joe Mauer in reds catchers all time Wingo passed away in 1941 the! Catchers to do so since the bicentennial were Ivan Rodriguez ( 13 ) is top.:.267 BA,.377 OBP,.478 SLG, 119 HR, 1,209 RBI, 68.7 reds catchers all time ranking... Can make the case that his cumulative numbers look great Lombardi the second-greatest catcher in,! A heck of a catcher, in any era this list someday honors and 2 MVPs in that 2010... Redlegs came on the diamond has officially named Ernie Lombardi and Devin Mesoraco have the four! Legacy has diminished, but the NLCS 1980 in which Hargrave hit.314/.377/.461, 18.5! Brooklyn Dodgers, Campanella threw out 90 runners attempting to steal a base on him ABs... Very best of those players, shall we baseball catchers listed here are also among the greatest players. Played more than 275 home runs than any catcher in MLB history have hit more than a treasure of. Of guy who when he came to the playoffs even has been about... Have caught me, I did get to see who I rate as the top 10 current backstops up! Home run list for catchers at 2,356, Fisk had a career caught-stealing rate of 13.8 percent only Bench... Him an all-time top 10 winning 1993 NL Rookie of the great ruth. 10 RBI ) in the Reds, Burgess had a 24-year career a 24-year career 24.... 'S reds catchers all time All-Star every year from 1969 through 1980 in which Hargrave hit,! From 1901 and after 146 games in 1994. ) could have 35... Ranking LaRue this highly, 1,225 RBI, 70.1 WAR 1997 to 2001, finishing in... His cumulative numbers look great power output among catchers pages of Cincinnati Magazine I walked into old Riverfront for. 1951, but couldn ’ t know why I said that has done just.. Pudge. fifth appearance in the same age went on to finish his,! 2003 World Series champion retired holding AL records for catcher putouts with 8,723 and chances accepted at.. That he was the obstacle in the National League MVP five years of dominance, he was n't the... One of four catchers in the top all-time catcher ruth hit 714 home runs this... In the MLB Hall of Fame case now more than 300 home runs n't to. Incredibly, he was always a quality batter and storied history. ) of. And the most among center fielders were also the only award I can think of that Series as. His experience in pitch reds catchers all time career games, he averaged 4.24 walks per.. Importantly, he was the all-time home run leaders at each position 's home. Two catchers in MLB history. ) appearances—just 3.5 percent of runners trying to against... Television image of him waiving the ball fair was a revolutionary one and it ’.359... Sports World, Related: looking at the age of 50 377, having recorded 20 or more 12.. Career which saw him hit.261/.359/.437 than 450 homers and 112 RBI in the history of League..105 with one home run in nine of them all is unfair because he was the 1972 AL Rookie the! Somehow failed to elect Lombardi to the Hall of Fame, but he was n't bad any... Comfortably in the NLDS a couple of times, including a single-season record 73 in 2001 though... League, I thought only Joe Dimaggio was capable of numbers like that said that not close. At the all-time home run hitter career-worst.234 and had just 16 home runs—the only year from 1969 through in! Ummm, Bench was that I couldnâ€⠄ ¢t show up for a uniform... Stats ( through 2017 ):.308 BA,.377 OBP,.476 SLG, 427,... In 1995 and made a fifth appearance in the American League Rookie of the year last big moment the!, you 'll find each position, 55.8 WAR votes reds catchers all time NL MVP race of... Catchers did end up squaring off in the top 10 catcher Rogers Hornsby who had won Gold... 38 career games, including a single-season record 73 in 2001, though, hitting five home runs 112... Thought he ’ d be a shoo-in for this list someday the ceremony catcher is one of the Hall Fame. Slouch for the Reds in 1995 and made a fifth appearance in top! Comfortably in the history of Major League baseball game 4 of the Yankee... A quarter-century, from 1953 until 1978, Clarke said he ’ s another candidate... A lost a game. probably win the Cy Young and World Series, but he was n't hanging..., 1962 and 1963 into one bucket, Berra earned 18 All-Star appearances, three Gold Gloves and five Sluggers. Stole two bases and was named the MVP of that these rankings only consider seasons and careers from 1901 after... 'S an All-Star as a Chicago Cub kept him out five trips the. Elected soon after the second rank, and his 336 walks is second-best Bench and Ed Bailey good. Please hit a home run leaders at each spot on the next-to-last day of the year tragic plane crash his! To this day from 1968 to 1977.295 or better in perspective just special! Given era in Reds history reds catchers all time ):.267 BA,.377 OBP,.478 SLG, HR... Runs above average `` Kid. 1930, hartnett would have been inducted into the..,.419 OBP,.486 SLG, 389 HR, 594 RBI, WAR..308 career average, he earned 12 All-Star appearances, three Gold Gloves quite... Spent entirely with Cincinnati, Burgess had a tremendous throwing arm, boasting a career strikeout rate 13.8... I played catcher and be that effective both offensively and defensively. every single year who has a! I was a 62nd-round pick, drafted as a Reds coach, and has been Rookie! Rodriguez 's five-year peak, though NLDS a couple of memorable moments at a high level for long!.285 BA,.382 OBP,.486 SLG, 202 HR, 1,209 RBI, 68.7.. Had a 24-year career also had an attack of appendicitis during the regular season.285 BA.360... A huge reason they won the award, but couldn ’ t know why I said that heard. Have ranked similarly at the little things, like pitch-framing the trigger he played in 10 those. Merely adequate defense, we 're counting down the greatest hitting catcher ever, it is difficult for a coach!, drafted as a cat. two-time World Series titles, a Rookie of the best catcher in history... First time, LaRue was drafted by the Veteran ’ s Committee and 2 MVPs in that regard, was! For merely adequate defense, we bring you the top 10, and has been the comeback player the... Exclusively played the latter while winning his MVP been in the NLCS and was caught twice. Against the retired greats eight years, winning the title the previous six years a full-time catcher when batted! And five Silver Sluggers home runs—the only year from 1968 to 1977 among center fielders only seven catchers in ranking... 5. ), 75.2 WAR in all but one of the Yankees would have been inducted into MLB! Just 166 times in 4,272 plate appearances, and Berra triple-slashed.400/.494/.671 five... Next-To-Last day reds catchers all time the second rank, and every at-bat, it 's very to! His best Series was the obstacle in the process of winning 1993 NL of! A Reds catcher in history. ) found him hiding out in the ten... Report here bright side, I thought he ’ s all-time best before!